MEDIA RELEASE – Webb-Shanahan Report exposes inaction by Minister Cahill
Published on 21 October 2026

The North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency (NAAJA) is calling on Minister for Children and Families, Robyn Cahill, to explain her inaction over the past two years in addressing systemic failings in the child protection system which leave vulnerable children at risk.

The Webb-Shanahan Report, released yesterday on 20 October 2026, confirmed what the sector has warned for years: the Department of Children and Families is failing children and families.

The final report calls for a system-wide reset of the Department’s child protection function.

“The Report is clear about what went wrong. It was not a lack of statutory authority or protective mechanisms. It was the timeliness and effectiveness of the Department’s identification, assessment and response to risk. Not one of the 45 recommendations calls for changes to the law,” NAAJA CEO Ben Grimes said.

“In other words, the law was not the problem. Yet the Minister has spent much of the last two years focused on changing the law. That is time she should have spent on fixing the problems in her Department.

“The Report confirms the clear messages and warnings NAAJA and other front-line organisations have been delivering to the Minister over the past two years.”

Warnings ignored

Warnings about failings in the Department came long before the tragic passing of Kumanjayi Little Baby.

In May 2025, NAAJA urged the government to focus on the practical barriers to better outcomes for children:

“NAAJA strongly recommends that the Department focus on addressing the practical barriers that are currently hindering better outcomes for children and young people in the Northern Territory, rather than focus of a review of the Care Act. This includes the recruitment and retention of highly skilled caseworkers; the provision of ongoing and specialised training and development for caseworkers; expediting carer assessments so more children in care can be placed with family; properly resourcing Aboriginal family led decision-making and mediation programs; and further investing in early intervention support programs with the aim of working with families and obviating the need for court proceedings. These are the kinds of reforms that address the everyday challenges of the system and that will deliver real change for the community.”

In February 2026, a coalition of legal services including NAAJA called on the Minister to work with her Department to strengthen the implementation of existing frameworks, stabilise and build the capacity of the child protection workforce and properly resource frontline services.

The Legislative Scrutiny Committee heard the same message from across the sector: amending the Care Act would not fix the problems in the Department.

“There still has not been a clear answer to why legislative changes were rushed and implemented before the government’s own report. If a report was required, the report should have come first, before legislative changes were considered,” Mr Grimes said.

A pattern, not a one-off

The Webb-Shanahan Report has expressly focused on the circumstances of Kumanjayi Little Baby, but identified inter-connected shortcomings across the child protection system.

This is part of a pattern. Every time the Department has come under scrutiny, serious failings have been identified.

Four coronial findings have been handed down since the Minister started: many of the Coroner’s findings are substantially similar to findings in the Webb-Shanahan Report.

  • Inquest into the Death of Baby G: the Department failed to conduct independent and thorough investigations of notifications, and that part of the reason the child was brought into care was the Department’s failure to identify and deliver family support services.
  • Inquest into the Death of Kailab Moir: the Department failed to properly meet the child’s medical needs, including a “serious oversight” in failing to facilitate a FASD assessment. Department staff were unable to access critical information relevant to children in their care.
  • Inquest into the Death of Didbala: staff shortages meant that the Department could not provide the level of case management necessary to properly care for a young person with complex needs. This led to case management neglect, including the failure to progress an NDIS application in a timely fashion.
  • Inquest into the Death of Kumanjayi Johnson: the Department failed to meet service standards due to staff shortages. There were “clear and apparent inadequacies” in care planning which were found to be a systemic problem.

“Urgently needed reforms to the Department could have begun much sooner if the Minister had paid attention to the Coroner’s recommendations,” Mr Grimes said.

    A Government that won’t listen

    This is part of a dangerous pattern that prevents meaningful and effective change from occurring.

    The Government passed its amendments to the Care Act despite nearly 130 of the 150 submissions to the Legislative Scrutiny Committee calling on the Bill to be scrapped or substantially amended. It passed them on the same day it tabled the Interim Report which found the problem was not a lack of legal powers.

    The Minister has not attended a single meeting of the Children and Families Tripartite Forum, the principal source of advice to the NT and Commonwealth governments on children and families, despite repeated requests.

    On this, as with many other issues, Aboriginal communities, frontline services and experts have told the Government what was needed. Each time, the Government has gone its own way. And each time, it is Aboriginal children and families who live with the consequences, and we now have two years of wasted time that should have been directed to reforming the Department.

    Government decisions continue to make things worse

    The Report found that front-line staff lacked clear and consistent guidance. The Government’s rushed amendments have deepened these existing failures.

    “The Department has still not updated its policies, procedures and practice frameworks, and the Court has been unable to explain how parts of the new legislation operate. The rushed legislative changes exacerbate the very problems identified by the Report and are already contributing to increased instability in the Department, including key staff resignations,” Mr Grimes said.

    “The Report found that staffing pressures and vacancy rates directly affected the Department’s capacity to respond. Yet right now, the rushed closure of the YiSSA short stay accommodation facility and the move of residents to Batchelor has seen Department staff redeployed to run that facility, placing further pressure on front-line staff and diverting resources from front-line child protection work,” Mr Grimes said.

    “The Report is clear that reform requires sustained commitment, investment in the workforce, and a strengthening of prevention and early intervention. The Minister must now say what additional resources will be provided to the Department and sector, and by when.

    “The Minister has had two years to fix these well-known problems. Instead she pursued an ideological agenda about legislation that ignored the evidence and the experts, and delayed the reforms so desperately needed to fix the child protection system.

    “She must provide an accounting for her inaction and give a clear commitment to engage with frontline organisations and experts so that she avoids repeating the same mistakes and continuing to fail families and children.”

     

    ***ENDS***

    Media contact and enquiries 

    media@naaja.org.au

    www.naaja.org.au